If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, we may receive an affiliate commission. Learn more about our policies and reviews.
When it comes to mascara there are so many different options to choose from and if you’re looking for one that stays in place all day long, we have got you covered.
We rounded up all of our favorite long-wearing mascaras that not only stay put all day, but they also add length and volume to your lashes. Not all long-wearing mascaras are waterproof, which many people aren’t too fond of, so we rounded up a mix of all of our top picks, which you can see below.
Below we’ve included a variety of fabulous choices from a 2-in-1 lengthening and volumizing mascara to a waterproof option, 4D silk fiber pick, and so many more.
No matter what type of longlasting mascara you’re looking for, there’s an option for everyone included in our list!
Our Picks of the Hottest Long Wearing Mascara
Clinique Lash Power Mascara Long-Wearing Formula — Best Overall
If you’re looking for a mascara that stays in place all day but isn’t too dramatic, this is the one for you. It is great for everyday use because it adds volume and length to your lashes without being too dark and fancy. The mascara lasts up to 24 hours and stays put through humidity, sweat, or tears. It has a unique brush that reaches the roots of your lashes all the way to the tips in one swipe and it’s ophthalmologist tested.
Pros
- It stays put for up to 24 hours
Cons
- It can be thick
Rimmel Scandaleyes Retroglam Mascara — Runner Up
Want to add a little boost to your lashes? Look no further than this Rimmel long-wear mascara which has an hourglass-shaped brush that hugs the roots of your lashes to add some volume. The brush grabs the roots to the tips to provide maximum length and fullness while staying in place all day. It doesn’t clump and the brush shape allows you to glam up your smaller lashes and even your bottom lashes.
Pros
- It has an hourglass-shaped brush
Cons
- You may need to apply a few coats
Midenso 4D Lash Mascara — Honorable Mention
Your mascara will stay in place all day long with this 4D silk fiber waterproof mascara. It is non-toxic and safe for sensitive skin and eyes, plus there’s a 100% satisfaction and a money-back guarantee if you run into any problems with the product. The mascara comes in a gorgeous sparkly rainbow tube and the brush is made of elastic silicone which makes it easy to reach hard places.
Pros
- It is waterproof
Cons
- It may be hard to remove
Buying Guide: Long Wearing Mascaras
A good mascara can change your entire look, but finding one can leave you looking through shops and websites endlessly. Well, we’re here to assist you by passing along some tips and tricks that you can keep in mind to ace the look that you’ve been looking for.
Things to Consider When Choosing Long Wearing Mascaras
So, what do you take into account before buying long mascaras? These mascaras can make your lashes look darker by giving them volume. But still, you need to keep a few things in check, right? We’ll list them down for you one by one.
Honesty
You must be wondering why we added honesty here. After all, this guide is for helping you buy long-wearing mascaras, right? Well, these days you will find countless beauty products claiming things left and right. They make their product sound different so they end up claiming something that might not even be true. This is what you need to watch out for. Finding a reliable mascara is challenging, especially because you never know how the product works unless it is branded.
Branded mascaras are usually worth it and chances are they won’t disappoint you. So let’s say the mascara you are buying claims to be naturally creamy. But once you apply it, your lashes feel stiff and hard. What do you do? Get the seller while they’re still there! Jokes apart, we don’t recommend you to purchase long-wearing mascaras from unknown dealers or manufacturers. Especially if you are going to a party or an important event. If you’re experimenting on your own for fun, then there’s no harm in taking out the mascara for a test drive.
Application process
Long-wearing mascaras are popular because they can add depth to your eyelashes with ease. However, it gets difficult if the wand is too big. This will make it difficult for you to maneuver the mascara and there are chances that you may end up creating a look that you do not approve of. It is better to go for smaller wands because they are easy to apply. Worst case scenario, you may hurt your eye by poking the tip of the mascara in it. A shorter wand, on the other hand, will have more control and you would be able to brighten your lashes without a lot of effort.
Removal process
Both the application and removal process are closely connected. Do you ever come back from a party and feel tired, but you can’t hit the hay because you’ve mascara in your eyes? Chances are, you will have to scrub for hours until you start to look normal. If you want to avoid doing that ever again, go for a mascara that doesn't smudge. Plus, if the long-wearing mascara has a nourishing formula then even if you sleep without removing it your eyes won’t sustain damage.
Speaking of eyes, scrubbing them repeatedly to get rid of mascara can harm your eyes. The skin that surrounds our eyes is extremely sensitive. Scrubbing it can result in eye irritation and eye damage as well. So not only is your eye mascara supposed to be easy to remove, its formula should include ingredients that are not harmful to your eyes.
Natural look
Do you ever come across people who have too much mascara on? Just by taking one look at them, you can tell that their mascara isn’t top-tier. Well, the formula is where the money is at. If the formula is poor, chances are it will reflect on your lashes without fail. Some people are experts at applying mascara but due to the low-quality mascara, they don’t look that appealing. Long-wearing mascara that looks clumpy won’t seal the deal for you. What you are looking for is a natural, simplistic look that allows you to fully cover your lashes with the mixture. Going from the roots of your lashes to the tip, that’s what you want.
Effectiveness
We’ll talk about two elements here: dryness and effectiveness. Firstly, what you want is for your long-wearing mascara to dry out quickly. If you are leaving for a party then you don’t want your mascara to take its sweet time, right? Plus, if you happen to touch your mascara while it's drying then you will end up spoiling your whole look. What you want, then, is for it to dry at a moderate pace because you also want to have a few coats while the mascara is setting on your lashes. This will create a unique, elegant look while offering your lashes the volume that you are looking for.
Time
This is something that all women chase. The most ideal mascara is one that lasts for the longest time. However, usually, long-wearing mascaras that last for a long time are made from harmful chemicals that can hurt your eyes. Plus, they are not good for your lashes in the long run. Women tend to keep up with mascara on their lashes for multiple hours throughout the day. In case the formula is low-quality, it will wear off in a few hours. This will force them to coat their lashes multiple times throughout the day.
Final Words
No matter which product you go for, remember to always check the ingredients first. Steer clear from long-wearing mascaras that have harmful chemicals in them. While you cannot totally avoid chemicals, we advise going for renowned brands as they test their products repeatedly to ensure that they don’t carry a lot of side effects with them. Truth be told, there’s nothing bad if your mascara offers lash growth as well so don’t be afraid to go for natural ingredients, they’re much better.
