If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, we may receive an affiliate commission. Learn more about our policies and reviews.
Mascara is one of those hero products that can make you look done even when worn alone. Mascaras and their wands come in all shapes, sizes, and colors, and whether you prefer lengthening, volumizing, or both, there is a mascara guaranteed to please.
Below we are focusing on lengthening the lashes with our top picks for the premier lengthening mascaras of 2024. We have sourced a few different options on Amazon, from some little-known brands and drugstore faves, that all keep the focus on making your lashes the longest they can be.
Choose from fiber-filled formulas that are filled with very small fibers that literally stick to the lashes giving them temporary volume and length and waterproof or non-waterproof formulas that easily come off with soap or your favorite cleanser and have a wear time of up to 24 hours if needed.
Great Lengthening Mascara Worth Considering in 2024
L'Oreal Paris Mascara — Best Overall
L’Oreal’s classic Telescopic Mascara is all about intense lengthening and unique lash separation. It uses a patented flexible precision brush that will lengthen lashes up to 60% while the comb side of the brush precisely separates lashes for clump-free, lash-by-lash separation. This formula is smooth for easy application, is fragrance-free, and removes easily with soap and water or your favorite makeup remover.
Pros
- This mascara is allergy-tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
Cons
- It may take several coats to achieve the desired look
Poppy Austin Mascara — Best Vegan Mascara
Next up, we have this lovely mascara from Poppy Austin. The first thing to note about this mascara is that it's 100% vegan-friendly and cruelty-free, which means it contains no animal by-products and is never tested on animals. It's also 100% organic, free of parabens and other unwanted elements. Made in Canada, this mascara aims to nourish the eyelashes with natural volumizing ingredients, while also making them appear thicker and fuller. Enriched with argan oil, it's capable of boosting the look and fullness of every lash, and it's suitable for all-day use, with every application capable of lasting a full 24 hours.
Pros
- Animal-friendly and cruelty-free
- The long-lasting formula for all-day use
- Adds volume and shine
Cons
- The brush is sometimes awkward to use
Bestidy Mascara — Runner Up
Another great fiber-filled mascara is the 4D Fiber Mascara by Bestidy. This is another waterproof formula that provides incredible volume and length to your lashes with just one coat or allows you to build the look for even thicker and more defined lashes. As this is a waterproof formula, this mascara will be long-lasting to ensure your lashes stay long, thick and voluminous all day long. You can also expect a long-lasting curl, and an easy-to-remove, creamy formula that won’t clump, flake, or dry out.
Pros
- The tube and packaging are super chic and will look great on any vanity
Cons
- It is advised to test a small amount of the product at the base of the lashes prior to use
Honest Beauty Mascara — Honorable Mention
The 2-in-1 primer and mascara by Honest Beauty is a unique and convenient option when it comes to applying your daily mascara. This multitasking makeup contains a primer and mascara that when applied work to create lush length, volume and definition. On one side of the tube is a primer that you use first to coat your lashes to create an even base and enhance the mascara’s lash-lengthening performance. Wait 30 seconds, then apply the mascara end to both the upper and lower lashes and build to the desired length.
Pros
- The specially molded bristles of the mascara wand pick up and separate every lash for dramatic definition without clumping
Cons
- This is not a waterproof mascara
Tetyana Naturals Mascara — Contender
Tetyana’s 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara uses an advanced thickening formula to create softer and fuller-looking lashes while boosting the length instantly with its fiber-filled formula. One coat is all it takes to achieve longer, thicker lashes, and its buildable formula allows for a second coat for even bolder lashes. This mascara will not flake, smudge or clump and when applied in the morning will last all day.
Pros
- This mascara should easily wash off with soap and water or for faster removal, use an oil-based remover
Cons
- Make sure to tighten the cap after use so it will not dry out
COVERGIRL Mascara — Also Consider
Covergirl’s Exhibitionist Uncensored Mascara is an update on their popular Exhibitionist formula and is an ultra-volumizing and lengthening mascara to crate full, defined lashes. This is a long-lasting, 24-hour formula that will easily take you and last from day to night and is available in waterproof and non-waterproof options. This mascara won’t flake or smudge and is infused with coconut and jojoba oils for hydration and volume.
Pros
- Feel good using this mascara as all Covergirl products are cruelty-free
Cons
- This mascara may take longer to dry
MOSTORY Mascara — Another Option
The lengthening mascara by Mostory is an intense black mascara that, on the first coat, will give you the appearance of longer, curlier, and more volumized lashes. Its specially designed, 2-in-1 silicone brush has different sized bristles on each side making coating each individual lash easy. The short side of the brush delivers the most intense curl while the longer side gives your lashes a lengthened and separated finish. This mascara also has a waterproof, long-lasting formula for 24-hour wear time if needed.
Pros
- This mascara contains only natural and non-toxic ingredients and is hypoallergenic
Cons
- It is not necessary to apply more than two coats
Buyer’s Guide: Lengthening Mascaras
Mascara can be the ultimate game-changer for your eye makeup, especially if you’re not a fan of falsies. The long, curled lashes can enhance even the simplest eye look and open up your eyes more. And with masks sticking around and covering more than half of our faces, using the best eye makeup for keeping the focus on the eyes is a smart thing to do. Keep reading to learn more!
The Two Mascara Wands for Maximum Length – Explained
Different mascara wands will help you achieve a different goal. Here are the most common two types of wands that are particularly great for adding length to your lashes. If you’re looking for the best mascara wands in 2023, make sure it has one of these two wands explained below for the best results:
Comb bristle wand
This wand type is excellent for volumizing and lengthening your eyelashes while adding a lot of drama to your eyes. The more you coat, the more dramatic your eyelashes will appear. Adding the formula will give your lashes the length you desire for a fluttery look. However, over-layering using this wand may end up clumping your lashes together, so avoid that.
Skinny wand
Add more definition to your eyes by enhancing the length of your eyelashes with the skinny wand. They provide depth to sparse eyelashes while efficiently separating each lash for a cleaner look. If you already have thicker lashes, this wand will work best for adding the desired length without clumping them up.
This is the ultimate wand for adding length, so in case you’re looking for massive volume, this wand will not work for you.
What Makes the Top Lengthening Mascara – Features
Who doesn’t love long, feathery lashes? But other than the dizzying variety of lashes, we now also have alternative options such as extensions and falsies. And while extensions sound promising, they can be time-consuming, high-maintenance, and pricey. Not to forget, the procedure may end up damaging your own lashes if not done right.
Falsies, on the other hand, can be a whole lot of a struggle too. And now we’re back to the mascaras! But it is, undoubtedly, the fastest, most effective way to add length and volume to your lashes. If that’s the kind of convenience you’re looking for, check out the following features in the best lengthening mascara to make sure it works.
Buildable
Look for a customizable formula that allows you to build up your mascara as you like. This gives you more control over the length and intensity of your eyelashes with each application. A formula that isn’t too thick or sticky is what you need. This will keep your lashes from clumping even after several coatings and give you the desired look.
Long-lasting
When it comes to mascaras, this feature goes without saying. You need something that is not only smudge-proof but also long-lasting. A good mascara is long-wearing and keeps looking fresh even after hours of applying it.
It is crucial to not have to worry about your mascara melting, especially if you live in humid regions.
High impact wand
High-impact wands designed to add length to your lashes should be your first choice. A wand that helps perfectly shape your lashes and individually works on each lash for adding length and dimension is what you need. As mentioned above, comb-bristle wands and skinny wands are great to achieve fluttery lashes.
Tips to Apply a Lengthening Mascara
Dreaming of long, feathery lashes without opting for expensive procedures? Here’s what you need to do:
- Start out by placing tissue paper under your eyes to keep any fallout from ruining your face makeup
- If you have an eyelash primer, go on with that first. Skip this step if you don’t have that product
- Always wipe off the mascara wand on the mascara opening to clean the excessive product out
- Look straight into the mirror and start with coating the outer lashes from the root to the tip, making your way to the inner corner as you continue. Repeat the process with another layer
- If required, add another layer before the first two dry out completely
- Repeat the same steps for the other eye
- If you notice excess product clinging onto your lashes, use a lash comb to gently brush it out. Let it dry completely and enjoy the results
