If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, we may receive an affiliate commission. Learn more about our policies and reviews.
Ponytail holders are absolutely essential for everyday use and there are a variety of different types to choose from. Whether you have thick, thin, curly, or straight hair, there are loads of hair ties to choose from and we rounded up all of our favorite picks.
We rounded up a slew of the quality ponytail holders of 2024 for all different hair types below and some of our favorite picks include seamless, plastic coils, ribbons, and more. While plastic coils may sound strange as a hair tie, the spiral shape actually alleviates the pressure on your hair, which prevents dents and knicks.
There are all different options below – from 100 packs to plain black simple elastics, and no matter what type of ponytail you’re looking for, there is something for everyone on our list and you will be sure to love them!
Our Favorite Ponytail Holder Worth Considering in 2024
Kenz Laurenz 100 Hair Ties — Best Overall
Included in this variety set are 100 seamless ribbon tie hair elastics that don’t crease your hair. They come in a variety of amazing colors and they’re great for medium to thick hair. Plus, they’re made of a super soft, stretchy material and they look cute when left on your wrist.
Pros
- It comes with 100 hair ties
Cons
- You don’t get to pick the colors
L. Erickson Grab & Go Ponytail Holders — Runner Up
This set comes with 8 ponytail holders in a variety of colors that are made with a soft woven material that doesn’t hurt or damage your hair. The hair ties are suitable for all hair types and they’re super cute as they have a little bead accent on them. They’re made with a thick durable elastic which keeps your hair in place no matter what hairstyle you’re rocking – a bun or a ponytail.
Pros
- They come in a variety of colors
Cons
- They can get stretched out
Kitsch Spiral Hair Ties — Honorable Mention
Included in this pack of hair ties are 8 ponytail holders in a plastic spiral shape which prevents your hair from getting tangled, thus preventing hair damage or breakage. The Brunette Pack comes with different shades of brown hair ties that work well with all hair types. Plus, they don’t dent your hair because the spiral shape is designed to alleviate the “pressure” that hair ties cause, leading to bumps and knicks in your hair.
Pros
- They don’t get tangled in your hair
Cons
- They’re made out of plastic
Goody Ouchless Women's Hair Braided Elastic — Contender
This set of ponytail holders comes with 27, 4mm metal-free hair ties that are all made with “Smart Stretch Core” technology which is 40% stronger than most elastics, allowing these hair ties to not lose their shape. They’re perfect for pulling your hair back any time, anywhere, and they keep your hair in place all day long. The hair ties specifically work well on medium to thick hair.
Pros
- 27 hair ties come in a pack
Cons
- They’re all one color
Thick Seamless Cotton Hair Bands — Also Consider
Never run out of a ponytail holder again thanks to his pack of 100 seamless hair ties which come in neutral colors of black, gray, brown, and tan. They’re all made of a thick & durable elastic that can keep your hair in place without slipping, plus, they’re seamless so they don’t leave dents in your hair. Each hair tie is 2 inches in diameter and the smooth seamless fabric prevents snagging or breaking of your hair.
Pros
- They’re seamless
Cons
- They can stretch out if pulled too tight
Buyer’s Guide to Finding a Ponytail Holder
How to Find the Top Ponytail Holders?
Since hair ties and ponytail holders are a useful part of our lives and it is important to consider the best types. Otherwise, you can end up spending most of your day trying to yank the ponytail holder out of your hair or trying to straighten out the crimp it left. Whatever the situation is, having a good-at-its-job ponytail holder that is going to not only solve your problems but actually end up making your life better and more convenient, is key. Hence, we have for you a list of different hair tie options that your strands are bound to thank you for.
Silk
It’s no secret that silk pillowcases are good for your hair. They are gentle on your scalp and help prevent any breakage or splitting caused by tossing and turning in bed all night. So naturally, ponytail holders made from silk are also the best thing you can tie up your hair with. Since silk is a soft and gentle fabric, these hair elastics don’t cause any breakage and look super chic too wrapped around your smooth locks. Silk also has the added advantage of making your hair look super smooth and less frizzy even after you take it off after use. This is because silk as a fabric helps tame down the friction and leave your hair looking shiny.
Scrunchies
This ‘90s favorite trend has been quite the rave in recent years and that should speak volumes about its functionality and chicness. It’s not possible to go about your life in today’s world and not come across a bunch of scrunchies. Given the fact that its entire design is based on the extra gathered fabric wrapped around the elastic, you can’t really be surprised that it’s a kind option for your hair.
Let’s talk about how trendy scrunchies can make your outfit look. A simple dressed-down look can easily be elevated with a scrunchie, making it look like you put a lot of effort into getting ready when all you did was wrap a quick scrunchie around your locks. Still not sure? Just pair a nice bright red scrunchie with an all-black outfit and you’ll see what we mean about elevating your look.
Coiled
You might have come across these coiled hair ties in beauty stores and thought, what a peculiar shape for a hair tie. Well, you weren’t all that wrong to think that. These ponytail holders do come in a strange coiled shape, something we haven’t really seen before. However, the comfort and ease they provide overlook everything else, even the strange shape. This hair tie might be something new for you but trust us when we say your hair is going to thank you for using them. The phone cord look helps prevent dents and marks that hair ties usually make after having been used for a little while. They also help you avoid headaches and unnecessary hair pulling and yanking, making them a gentle option for your hair. They usually come in a clear design which provides you with endless wearability. However, now that they’ve become increasingly common, you can opt for some colorful options too to match your outfits. What could be better?
Bungee bands
This is another non-traditional option as these are great at ensuring that the weight of your locks isn’t unevenly distributed, putting extra strain on your strands. So, if you have thick hair that is difficult to tie up or hair that just doesn’t stay put then these bungee bands will be useful for you. The fabric on this is connected with a hook and loop mechanism that only needs you to gather your hair and attach it to secure your mane.
Ribbon elastics
This one is THE option for all the girly girls out there! Some ribbon hair elastics are a nice way to add some oomph to your look and chic it up. Hair elastics made from ribbon allow it to be smooth against your hair, preventing friction and breakage.
Hair scarves
And last but certainly not the least is the option of a hair scarf or wrap. This is the age-old way of tying up your hair that is too versatile to ever go out of style. Perfect for summer and spring both, you can use the scarf any way in any style you like, including wrapping it around your hair and tying it into place with the ends hanging down, making for one pretty look. You can check the endless amount of tutorials online and find different and unique ways to use a hair scarf. One thing we’ll say about them, is they can never really go out of style!
