Hailey Baldwin & Justin Bieber: She Was Pushed Out Of His Party By Yovanna Ventura

Hailey was the #1 woman in Justin's life for a while, but when he celebrated his 21st birthday on a private island, he only had eyes for ex-fling Yovanna! That's exactly why a heartbroken Hailey fled the island early, a source tells HollywoodLife.com exclusively. When Hailey Baldwin deserted Justin Bieber, in the middle of his Caribbean birthday celebration, we had a hunch there was trouble in paradise -- and it turns out we were right! Hailey was super hurt that the Biebs was giving Yovanna Ventura, 19, "all his attention" during the getaway, a source tells HollywoodLife.com exclusively. Here's what went wrong.

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Hailey Baldwin Left Justin Bieber’s Party Because Of Yovanna Ventura Flirtation

Hailey, 18, might be okay with Justin, 21, seeing other girls but that does not apply when she’s in the same room — or in this case, on the same island — with him!

“Hailey left because Justin was giving Yovanna all his attention,” a source tells HollywoodLife.com EXCLUSIVELY. “She’s not his girlfriend and she tries to be cool but she’s not gonna be second best to some random girl.”


“She says she’s cool with him being with other girls, but putting it in her face like that was too much,” our source adds.

Hailey didn’t want to make a scene so when she’d had enough, she packed her suitcase and headed for the airport on Tuesday, March 3.

“She didn’t throw a big fit, she didn’t pick a fight with Yovanna, she just left,” our source reveals. “She was supposed to stay until the end of the week but she bounced early. She’s not going to stay in a situation like that. She’s telling people she’s over it and doesn’t care but it’s messed up what he did.”

Poor Hailey! We totally understand why she’s so hurt. It’s one thing if she and Justin have an understanding about him seeing other girls, but to flaunt his flirtations right in her face is crossing the line!

Hailey Baldwin Deserts Justin Bieber On Private Island & Disses Him On Twitter

Hailey first raised relationship red flags when she posted the following message on her Twitter on March 3:

When one of Justin’s Twitter followers asked Hailey if she left the island because he was being a jerk, she replied: “I didn’t have to leave for that, left because I wanted to :).”

But HollywoodLife.com has also exclusively learned that Hailey feels threatened by Yovanna’s hold on Justin.

“Hailey isn’t showing it on the outside, but she is threatened by Justin’s rekindled relationship with Yovanna. Hailey isn’t Justin’s number one anymore. Look at all that Hailey has gotten from being with Justin, and to lose that really has put the fear in her. We might be in for a cat fight,” a source told HollywoodLife.com EXCLUSIVELY.

So what do YOU think, HollywoodLifers? Should Hailey give Justin a second chance or forget about him? Let us know!

— Susan Johnson