Kidnapped Carlina White Is Still Estranged From Her Birth Mother. Experts Tell Us Why!

Tue, February 8, 2011 1:04pm EST by 3 Comments

Experts explain that feelings of guilt and pressure are keeping Carlina from bonding with her birth mom, Joy White.

So sad. As if waiting 23 years to be reunited with your kidnapped child isn’t hard enough, now Joy White is saying that her biological daughter Carlina White, who goes by Nejdra Nance, is estranged once again. On this morning’s Today, a teary-eyed Joy confessed that Carlina is no longer involved in her life. “It’s been pretty tough,” says Joy. “I wanted to have a relationship with my daughter.”

Ann Pettway admitted to taking Carlina White

Relationship expert Dr. Gilda Carle tells that Carlina is probably confused about how to blend both families into her life. “She may be undergoing much guilt in being pressured to turn her back on her kidnappers,” says. Dr. Carle. “I think the girl must be very confused at this point, between finding her birth family AND all the media attention this story has attracted.”

After being reunited last month in the Bronx, where Carlina was taken by alleged kidnapper Ann Pettway from a hospital as an infant, Joy says her daughter has grown distant and greedy. “I was on such a high when I was reunited with my daughter,” Joy says. “I was floating on air. Everything seemed so great.” Although Joy appeared on Today, Carlina would not comment to the show and will reportedly only talk for money.

We thought it was such a happy ending!

But now, everything is not so great since Carlina packed her bags and moved back to Atlanta, Georgia after the family’s second visit, where Joy first noticed her daughter’s distant nature. “It really hurts, but I do understand that is her family. She was brought up by them. She’s with that family. That’s all she knows. [But] I’m her mother. It hurts not to have my daughter. I want her back,” a heartbroken Joy says.

According to Psychotherapist Jonathan Alpert, Carlina may be pulling away because of panic at the possibility of losing her birth mother again. “She could possibly be scared to get too close to her biological mother for fear of losing her again. Therefore she sabotages all efforts and opportunities to nurture a relationship with her,” he tells, adding that Carlina could also feel resentment towards her birth mom. “She may blame her for the kidnapping.”

“Certainly, one has to pity her birth parents, who found her after 2 decades, and had probably given up all hope, and now have seen her turn her back on them!” says Dr. Carle, who encourages Carlina to seek professional help. “I believe Carlina would benefit from some counseling to understand her true feelings about this unusual situation. She doesn’t have to choose one family over another,” explains Dr. Carle. “Carlina can use her situation as a way to expand herself and her love.”

“She needs to feel safe, secure and there needs to be reassurance that such an act won’t happen again,” agrees Alpert.

Elizabeth Smart had baby names picked out while in captivity

There are even questions about the $750,000 settlement Joy and her husband Carl Tyson got from the hospital after Carlina’s kidnapping. Joy tells Meredith Vieira that a large portion of that settlement was put into a trust for Carlina until she turned 21, but they ended up spending that money to support themselves and their other two children. “It hurts me that it’s about money,” says Joy.

But, the story gets stranger HollyMoms, because while Joy is claiming Carlina’s estranged, her husband, Carl Tyson, told CBS’s The Early Show this morning (Feb. 8 ) that he talks and texts with her every day! “I just wish she were close to me,” he said, in regards to the distance between his home in New York and her life in Atlanta.

–Leigh Blickley

Get more HollyBaby news and gossip! Friend us on Facebook, Follow us on Twitter and Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Leave a Reply

To comment, please fill in the fields below, enter your comment and select the Comment button.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

View Comment


Posted at 9:11 AM on May 10, 2014  

Its obvious ann wasn’t all there n what she did was terrible n hurtful but its more about carlina/neddy yes her biological parents have pain I can’t imagine what they went through but neddy is safe n secure by her family there not the enemy ann is.. and she is serving her time … I really think the final say should of been up to neddy shes grown n she forgave her n carl n joi it hard yall but thats the only way yall gne b n neddy life dnt make her choose your blessed to have her come back to u n she brought u a gbby to take up lost time…. it will take time but with gods help forgive ann day by day.. forgive but dnt forget…

Share this comment at Share with Twitter


Posted at 6:59 PM on May 25, 2011  

It must be very hard for Carlina for as much as she was snatched from her biological family, in her mind it is the kidnappers who are her family now. They’re all she’s ever known.

Share this comment at Share with Twitter


Posted at 2:39 PM on May 25, 2011  

How can there be a second family? Didn’t they get arrested for kidnapping? I mean they stole this baby right out of the hospital! God” they should be in jail!!!

Share this comment at Share with Twitter