Justin Bieber With Selena Gomez Vs. Hailey Baldwin: PICS

By:

December 14, 2018 5:11PM EST

1 of 7

Justin Bieber With Selena Gomez Vs. Hailey Baldwin

Justin Bieber With Selena Gomez Vs. Hailey Baldwin — Justin Bieber’s fans have been embroiled in a debate about who they favor him being in a relationship — Hailey Baldwin or Selena Gomez — ever since he rekindled his romance with Hailey in 2018. Justin and Selena dated on-and-off for nine years from 2009 until 2018. Their relationship was a tumultuous one that had very high highs and very low lows. Meanwhile, Justin and Hailey had always been friends since a young age. The two casually dated and hung out during the singer’s off periods with Selena. Justin and Hailey, who previously dated in 2015 and 2016, rekindled their romance in the summer of 2018. Justin proposed to Hailey while the two were on vacation in the Bahamas on July 7, 2018. The “No Brainer” singer popped the question in front of a packed crowd at Baker’s Bay Resort with a massive, oval-cut diamond ring. As of April 2019, the couple was still in the midst of planning their nuptials and had not set an official wedding date.

2 of 7

Jelena On V Day

Jelena On V Day — Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez celebrated Valentine’s Day together at dinner in 2018. She was all smiles in a black dress and a patterned blazer, while JB wore khaki pants and a jean jacket.

3 of 7

Justin & Hailey Bieber Out And About

Justin & Hailey Bieber Out And About — Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin enjoyed a walk together in NYC. The couple smiled big for paparazzi after they stopped at Starbucks.

4 of 7

Justin & Hailey Bieber On Beach

Justin & Hailey Bieber On Beach — Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin took a stroll on the beach. They were all smiles while they sipped on Starbucks. The model put her toned tummy on display, while Justin covered up in a white tank and shorts.

5 of 7

Jelena Grab Dinner

Jelena Grab Dinner — Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez were spotted eating dinner together after attending church on Valentine’s day in 2018.

6 of 7

Justin & Hailey Bieber In New York

Justin & Hailey Bieber In New York — Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin enjoyed the summer weather in NYC as they took a walk to see ‘Mission: Impossible.’ Hailey smiled at Justin as the two were casually dressed for their movie date.

7 of 7

Jelena Goes Cruising

Jelena Goes Cruising — Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez shared a ride after church on February 21, 2018. They looked serious as Bieber was behind the wheel.

Click to Subscribe to Get Our Free HollywoodLife Daily Newsletter to get the hottest celeb news.