The crowns haven’t slipped off these teen queens of the ’90s! Two decades have passed since stars like Sarah Michelle Gellar (left) and Jennifer Love Hewitt (right) shot to fame on the small and big screen, and life has taken each idol on a different path.

Her claim to fame is her starring role on Buffy the Vampire Slayer, but Sarah has since found joy in motherhood while raising her children Charlotte and Rocky. She’s planning a major comeback on TV, however, and will be starring in and executive producing the shows Sometimes I Lie and Other People’s Houses. Jennifer Love Hewitt is also staying faithful to the small screen, after making a name for herself on the ’90s series Party of Five. She’s currently starring on the Fox drama 9-1-1!

Check out the rest of HollywoodLife’s gallery to catch up with the following teen queens-turned-adults: Alicia Silverstone, Rachel Leigh Cook, Claire Danes, Katie Holmes, Neve Campbell, Mayim Bialik, Christina Ricci, Melissa Joan Hart, Selma Blair, Reese Witherspoon, Tatyana Ali, Mandy Moore, Danielle Fishel, Brandy Norwood and twins Tia and Tamera Mowry.