‘HIMYM’ Star David Henrie On The Finale: It Ended How It Should Have

Tue, April 1, 2014 8:13pm EDT by 7 Comments

Many fans are furious about ‘How I Met Your Mother’s’ shocking finale on March 31 — but ‘HIMYM’ star David Henrie, who played Ted’s son on the show, thought it couldn’t have been more perfect! ‘It ended on a nice note,’ David tells HollywoodLife.com EXCLUSIVELY.

How I Met Your Mother fans were shocked to find out that the jaw-dropping final scene featuring Ted’s kids (David Henrie and Lyndsy Fonseca) was actually filmed nine years ago during the show’s first season. Can you believe that David and Lyndsy knew all along that Ted would end up with [SPOILER]?! Now that it’s all over, David is finally opening up about the controversial ending that he kept under wraps for nearly a decade — and what he has to say might surprise you!

David Henrie On ‘HIMYM’ Finale: I Thought Robin Was The Mother

Nine years ago, David sat down with HIMYM showrunners Carter Bays and Craig Thomas to film what would eventually become a part of one of the most hotly anticipated finales in TV history. David signed a non-disclosure agreement that prohibited him from blabbing the secret at the time — “I didn’t even tell my mother who the mother was,” he says — but now he’s free to tell the tale!

“I have known all along what was going to happen, but I didn’t quite remember it. In my head I pictured it a little differently,” David tells HollywoodLife.com in an EXCLUSIVE interview. “I remember sitting down with the two showrunners and the whole set was evacuated. It was only me and the two showrunners. One of them turned to me and said, ‘I’m going to tell you guys the ending of the show. It’s gotta be Robin, right?'”

So crazy! But while David knew the gist of the ending, after nine years, the details had become a little blurry.

“We shot the scene and I totally forgot what the sister said about [Ted being in love with] Aunt Robin. I don’t think Lyndsy even remembers either. So in my mind this whole time I was thinking, there’s some twist, Robin’s the mom.”

Now THAT would have been really twisted!

David Henrie On ‘HIMYM’ Finale: Series Ended How It Should Have

So what does David think of the ending after all these years?

“It ended on a nice note and things ended how they should have,” he says. “There’s hope for Robin, Barney’s going to become a better man.” And as for the backlash over the finale, David jokes that disgruntled fans should “get over it!”

“People should be happy that they had nine years of getting to know these amazing characters on TV. Stop being greedy,” he says, laughing. “Be grateful.”

And even if fans aren’t happy with the ending, there are plenty of other moments to love from the finale.

“I think they sent a nice message to the audience with the Barney character … with his daughter. If you didn’t choke up in that moment, you have no heart. It was a beautiful moment. That was my favorite moment, seeing him look into his daughter’s eyes.”

David’s other favorite part about the finale? Now that the cat’s out of the bag, he won’t have HIMYM fans pressing him for answers anymore!

“I’m happy that I won’t be getting harassed at bars anymore,” he jokes.

So HollywoodLifers, are YOU happy with the series finale of HIMYM? Vote and share your thoughts in the comments below!

– Tierney McAfee

More ‘How I Met Your Mother’ News:

  1. ‘How I Met Your Mother’ Mother May Be Dead — Fans React
  2. ‘HIMYM’: Exes Invade Ted & Robin’s Romantic Trip Down Memory Lane
  3. ‘HIMYM’: The Mother Reveals How She Met Ted On 200th Episode