#1 Good Guy: J.P. Rosenbaum is the rumored winner and stuck by Ashley’s side through everything. He was the only one she trusted with her secrets, and he never complained when she cried on his shoulder!
#1 Bad Boy: Bentley Williams crushed Ashley. He left her thinking that he had feelings for her, while in fact he bashed her to the cameras. Then Bentley returned and tried to lie his way back into her heart.
#3 Good Guy: Ben Flajnik went through the most impressive change of the season. Instead of giving into his fear, he allowed Ashley to show him that he can love again. And that’s exactly what he offered her in return!
#2 Bad Boy: William Holman needs to learn to hold his tongue. He dissed Ashley to her face, saying he signed on for Emily Maynard to be The Bachelorette, not Ashley!
#4 Bad Boy: Drunk Tim McCormack got wasted during the first cocktail party in the season premiere. He didn’t even make it to the rose ceremony before Ashley sent him home.
#5 Good Guy: Ryan Park is the most romantic one. He flew all the way across the world to prove to Ashley that he loved her and tried to win her back!
#3 Bad Boy: Ryan “Mickey” McLean was too selfish to stick it out for Ashley. He left when he couldn’t handle the pressure of Ashley liking Bentley.
#2 Good Guy: Constantine Tzortzis is the most honest guy of the season. Instead of leading Ashley on, he said goodbye to her in the most respectful of ways!
#5 Bad Boy: Ben Castoriano may have been joking about wanting to do online dating after the show ended, but that’s never OK when you’re supposed to be there winning Ashley’s heart!
#4 Good Guy: Ames Brown is definitely the season’s sweetheart! He couldn’t say a bad thing about Ashley when she didn’t give him a rose during the hometown dates. Instead, he sang her praises!