Andy Cohen Reveals What Was In Lisa Rinna’s Manila Envelope At ‘RHOBH’ Reunion

Following Andy Cohen's Monday reveal of what was inside Lisa Rinna's manila envelope at the 'RHOBH' reunion, he then clarified that there was a second envelope he was not aware of.

Reading Time: 4 minutes
Lisa & Andy
View gallery
Image Credit: Charles Sykes/Bravo

Bravo TV personality Andy Cohen, 54, finally spilled the tea about what Lisa Rinna, 59, was carrying inside her manilla envelope at The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Season 12 reunion, per Page Six. “There’s lots of speculation of what was in the manila envelope let me tell you,” Andy said during the Oct. 31, episode of Andy Cohen Live. “What was in the manila envelope was [sic] receipts relating to the Elton John AIDS Foundation ticket snafu.” Although the moment was highly anticipated by viewers, it ultimately did not make the final edit because of time limits. “There were a lot of decisions made in the edit to cut down many conversations,” he added. But later, on Nov. 2, Andy went on his show to address Lisa’s Instagram story where she said she had not one, but two, manila envelopes with receipts.

lisa & andy
Lisa Rinna & Andy Cohen at ‘WWHL’. (Charles Sykes/Bravo)

After reiterating what he said on Monday, the TV executive went on to tell listeners how he confronted Lisa about her Instagram Story. “Well, I’m at the gym and I see it, and there’s a picture in the Page Six article where it says Aspen receipts. And I text [Lisa] Rinna, I go, ‘I said on the radio today that your receipts were about the Elton John AIDS thing. Is that what they were, Were there also Aspen receipts?’,” he began. “And she said, ‘Actually, there were also Aspen receipts.’ She said, ‘I printed out eight pages of text messages from texts that I was sending to Kyle [Richards] and Erika [Jayne]’ and, another friend of hers about what was going on that night with Kathy [Hilton].

“And she said, ‘That was kind of my corroboration, that I sent those texts that night. And that’s what that was.’ And we never, she never entered them to the court for consideration and we never got to them,” Andy added. The popular TV host also said that he believes both situations regarding the contents of the envelopes. “You know, So this is me saying I believe both of these situations to be true. She had the Elton John receipts, she had, what were her Aspen receipts that I never saw. We never got to them. We didn’t cut them out of the show. She never handed them over during the show. And so that is the tale of Rinna’s receipts,” he concluded.

The Elton John AIDS Foundation “snafu” that the 54-year-old was referring to was when Sutton Stracke, 51, claimed that Lisa and her husband, Harry Hamlin, 71, did not thank her for the invite to the event. “A few years ago Harry and Lisa both came – I invited them to the Elton John gala, and they came with me as my guests,” Sutton told Andy in Sept. 2021 during WWHL. “…I never got a thank you,” the Georgia native added. During the show, Lisa claimed that she was not a guest of Sutton’s and was personally invited by the “Rocket Man” singer. Of course, Sutton fired back, and told the host that she purchased Lisa and Harry’s $10,000 tickets. This drama continued to play out during Season 12, but the beef was never squashed because neither Sutton or Lisa were willing to come to an agreement.

Furthermore, Andy also told listeners why more drama from the show was left out of the reunion episodes. “Pretty much every topic we beat to death because that’s what we do,” he said. “We talked about a lot and we had a lot to get into three episodes,” Andy went on. “If it had been any longer, I feel like everyone would have complained it was too long, but now people are complaining, ‘Why didn’t you talk about this more, why didn’t you talk about that more?’​”

lisa & Andy
Andy Cohen revealed what was inside Lisa Rinna’s manila envelope during the Season 12 reunion of ‘RHOBH’. (Charles Sykes/Bravo)

Several fans of the show took to Twitter during the three reunion episodes to share their thoughts. “That reunion just wasn’t that satisfying. I guess it was good to finally see Kathy [Hilton] read Lisa Rinna and Erika [Jayne] but Andy barely challenged them and Kyle [Richards] didn’t either. Her sister is being accused of being evil and vile and Kyle is one the weeping,” one viewer wrote. A separate user chimed in and tweeted, “EXACTLY another build up for a let down, except the Kathy part of course!”

Season 12 of RHOBH aired from May 11 until the final reunion episode aired on Oct. 26. Many things were talked about during the reunion, but one of the most hilarious moments was when Dorit Kemsley, 46, left a spray tan stain on the reunion couch. Although the mom-of-two was not the main focus of the drama this season, she did have a rocky start as the season began with her traumatic home robbery where she was also held at gunpoint. The Beverly Beach founder also told HollywoodLife at this year’s BravoCon that was continuing therapy. “I am in therapy. Thank god for therapy,” Dorit shared.

More From Our Partners