Continue to Hollywoodlife () SKIP AD
Hollywood Life Logo Image

Hollywood Life

Today's Top Stories

  • Rihanna
    See Pics

    Rihanna Stuns In Retro Savage X Fenty Lingerie & Looks Like She Time-Traveled From The ’70s

  • Tiger Woods & family
    Exclusive

    Why Tiger Woods Doesn’t Want His Kids To Visit Him In The Hospital After Terrifying Car Crash

  • kettlebell
    SHOP

    Over 9,800 People Swear By This Kettlebell To Get Fit For Summer & It’s Under $100

Hollywood Life
  • Home
  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Celebrity Bios
  • Beauty
  • Fashion
  • Shopping
  • Celebrity News
  • World News
  • Exclusives
  • Politics
  • Celebrity Babies
  • Opinions
ALL NEWS
  • Lori Loughlin

    Lori Loughlin Pictured For The 1st Time Since Leaving Prison 2 Months Ago As New Netflix Doc Nears

  • Jason Sudeikis & Keeley Hazel Fuel Dating Speculation After Appearing To Be In The Same House: See Pics

  • Joe Biden Drags Texas & Mississippi Leaders For ‘Neanderthal Thinking’ After They Lift COVID Restrictions

  • Award Shows
  • At The Movies
  • TV
  • Music
  • Sports
  • Sex & Relationships
  • Holidays
  • Entertainment Features
  • Podcast
  • Oscar Contenders
ALL ENTERTAINMENT
  • ‘RHONJ’: Teresa Giudice Storms Off After New Rumors About Joe Gorga & Jackie’s Husband Surface

  • Kelly Marie Tran: 5 Things To Know About The ‘Raya And The Last Dragon’ Star

  • 20 Best Horror Movies on Netflix You Have to Watch

  • Taylor Swift
  • Rihanna
  • Selena Gomez
  • Kim Kardashian
  • Kylie Jenner
  • Kendall Jenner
  • Justin Bieber
  • Miley Cyrus
  • Gigi Hadid
  • Khloe Kardashian
  • Jennifer Lopez
  • Angelina Jolie
  • Harry Styles
  • Kourtney Kardashian
ALL CELEBRITY BIOS
  • Lori Loughlin

    Lori Loughlin Pictured For The 1st Time Since Leaving Prison 2 Months Ago As New Netflix Doc Nears

  • Jason Sudeikis & Keeley Hazel Fuel Dating Speculation After Appearing To Be In The Same House: See Pics

  • ‘RHONJ’: Teresa Giudice Storms Off After New Rumors About Joe Gorga & Jackie’s Husband Surface

  • Fragrance
  • Hair Care
  • Health
  • Makeup
  • Nails
  • Beauty Features
  • Skincare
  • Makeover
  • Diet & Fitness
ALL BEAUTY
  • Skincream

    One Jar Of This Best-Selling Neck Tightening Cream Sells Every Minute & You Can Shop It For Under $100

  • Stay Hydrated With These Top-Selling Smart Water Bottles That Track Your Water Intake

  • Over 9,800 People Swear By This Kettlebell To Get Fit For Summer & It’s Under $100

  • Red Carpet
  • Weddings
  • Fashion Features
  • Shopping
ALL FASHION
  • Rihanna

    Rihanna Stuns In Retro Savage X Fenty Lingerie & Looks Like She Time-Traveled From The ’70s

  • Khloe Kardashian Wears Nothing But Jeans In Sexy New Pic & Scott Disick Likes What He Sees: ‘Wow’

  • Brielle Biermann’s Hottest Bikini Pics Of All Time: See ‘Don’t Be Tardy’ Star Stun In Swimwear

  • Share This Article
  • Reddit
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Email
  • Print
  • Talk
Next Up

Coco Austin Reveals She & Ice-T Have A New ‘Mommy’ TV Show In The Works: It’s ‘Taboo’

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube
  • Newsletters
  • Search Close

Trending

  • Bonnie Says
  • Celeb Babies
  • TV
  • Celeb Galleries
  • Golden Globes
Search

NewsExpand Menu

  • Celebrity News
  • World News
  • Exclusives
  • Politics
  • Celebrity Babies
  • Opinions
  • Rock The Vote

EntertainmentExpand Menu

  • Entertainment Features
  • TV
  • Award Shows
  • At The Movies
  • Music
  • Sports
  • Sex & Relationships
  • Podcast
  • At Home With...

BeautyExpand Menu

  • Fragrance
  • Hair Care
  • Health
  • Makeup
  • Nails
  • Skincare
  • Beauty Features
  • Diet & Fitness
  • Shopping

FashionExpand Menu

  • Red Carpet
  • Weddings
  • Fashion Features
  • Shopping

TrendingExpand Menu

  • Bonnie Says
  • TV
  • Celeb Galleries
  • Golden Globes

About UsExpand Menu

  • About Us
  • Writer Bios
  • Scoops, Tips & Corrections
  • Subscribe To Newsletter
  • Contact Us

Celebrity ProfilesExpand Menu

  • Kim Kardashian
  • Kylie Jenner
  • Justin Bieber
  • Selena Gomez
  • Taylor Swift
  • Rihanna
  • Kendall Jenner
  • Miley Cyrus
  • Gigi Hadid
  • Jennifer Lopez
  • Angelina Jolie
Follow Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube
  • Newsletters
Alerts & Newsletters
  • Jobs
  • Scoops & Corrections
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • California Privacy Rights
  • AdChoices
  • Data Policy
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information
© 2021 Hollywoodlife.com, LLC.
  • Entertainment
  • At The Movies
  • Emma Watson
  • Tom Hanks
comment 2 Comments
April 28, 2017 1:13PM EDT

‘The Circle’ Review: Did Emma Watson’s Dystopian Movie Live Up To The Book?

Tom Hanks Emma Watson Patton Oswald The Circle
Image Courtesy of STX Entertainment
Emma Watson
Vanity Fair Oscar Party, Arrivals, Los Angeles, USA - 04 Mar 2018
Emma Watson
Vanity Fair Oscar Party, Arrivals, Los Angeles, USA - 04 Mar 2018
Emma Watson
75th Annual Golden Globe Awards, Arrivals, Los Angeles, USA - 07 Jan 2018
Emma Watson in Vintage Ralph Lauren
Wimbledon Tennis Championships, Day 13, The All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club, London, UK - 15 Jul 2018
WEARING VINTAGE RALPH LAUREN View Gallery View Gallery 11 Photos.
Dina Sartore-Bodo
Managing Editor
  • Share This Article
  • Reddit
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Email
  • Print
  • Talk

Fresh off the immense success of her last movie ‘Beauty & The Beast,’ Emma Watson is back on the big screen alongside Tom Hanks in the thriller ‘The Circle.’ But does the film live up to the book? Our editors — one who read the book and one who did not — review it here. WARNING: spoilers ahead!

Anyone whose ever loved a book so much it hurts knows the immense anxiety felt when that story is turned into the movie. So many factors go into making the flick just right and it can leave fans with many questions: Did they cast the right people? Did they leave in my favorite scene? Did they change the ending? Well, I had never read The Circle before checking out the film at it’s premiere at Tribeca Film Festival, so to make sure our review covered all our bases, Senior Entertainment Editor Emily Longeretta and I are tackling this one together from two points of view:  someone who has read the book, and someone who hasn’t. Let’s do this!

Emma Watson As Mae Holland, the film’s lead

Dina: “Who is Mae?” That’s honestly what I kept asking myself the entire movie, beginning to end. No question that Emma Watson is a phenomenal actress — and if Tim Cook ever needs a break, he should call her and Tom Hanks to host Apple’s annual product presentations. But I didn’t quite follow the arc of her character. How did she go from making fun of “The Circle” and their pod people to chugging down the Kool-Aid faster than you can say, “Oh Yeah?” It just didn’t really make sense. I felt like there was a lot missing about the development of her character. I wasn’t sure if I was meant to root for her as a heroine or pity her as a victim.

Emily: Mae wasn’t an exceptionally likable person in the book. Much like Emma’s version, she was a little bit all over the place — she lacked knowing what she actually wanted and flip-flopped from being upset over the death of someone she cared about to basically supporting the reason he died. To me, the film’s version of Mae was a little more likable, and that was probably because it’s really hard to dislike Emma. My one complaint: they should have just made her British — that accent was all over the place.

See More Photos From Tribeca Film Festival

John Boyega as Ty

Dina: He was just kind of there. He’s supposed to be the Mark Zuckerberg character, the man behind the curtain at the end of The Wizard of Oz, yet I felt like the whole time, he was just an after thought. He shows up at odd moments to fill in plot points for Emma’s character toward the beginning. Then he completely disappears for nearly an hour, only to show up again at the end to help Mae with her plan to take down The Circle. But he’s not even in the room when she does it! Something tells me this character was meant to be more important, but that John had to squeeze this in while filming The Last Jedi or something. In fact, in one scene, he’s merely superimposed into the crowd. It was just odd!

Emily: Coming from someone who actually loves John Boyega, this casting was so off. However, I guess that’s because this character was not even close to the one we grew to love in the book. John was fine, but he was in the film for what, a combined eight minutes if that? His big reveal as Ty, one of the “Wise Men” was anti-climatic and not only did you not even have time to care about his real identity, you probably didn’t even remember who Ty was.

The Circle’s Climatic Scene

Dina: That has to be — SPOILER ALERT — the death of Mae’s friend Mercer, which is broadcasted live after Mae goes “transparent.” It’s also perhaps the best scene in the whole movie: Emma’s acting is on point, the real threat of being part of the The Circle is realized, and Tom Hanks is there. The end.

Emily: I have to agree with Dina this time, since the whole Ty reveal didn’t even happen in the film and was played off as no big deal. However, did his death really change her? Not so much. I agree that the scene was great — kept you guessing, Tom Hanks was there (the best part of the entire thing), and Emma does a great job. My problem: it should have been the reveal of Ty. My other problem: Mae had no personal relationship with neither Ty or Mercer beforehand. In the book, Mercer was her ex-boyfriend who she was once in love with, and Ty was a man she had multiple hook ups with. This was a huge miss for me.

The Ending

Dina: Left me totally confused! Does she think The Circle is bad or good? After everything that’s happened — the death of her friend, the breakdown of her mentor, and the humiliation of her parents — how can she possibly believe that constant surveillance is a good idea?! And what happens to The Circle’s leaders? Are they put in jail for all the shady dealings? Is Ty the head of The Circle now? Is Mae? I had more questions leaving than I did coming in.

Emily: This one’s a positive for me. The ending of the film didn’t leave me satisfied in any way — why is she taking over the company? Is she even? What were in the leaders’ emails? However, it left me more satisfied than the book did. At least she retaliated a little bit for what had happened. In the film, Bailey and Stenton basically forced her to hunt down Mercer, and she ended up basically throwing their own “transparency” in their own faces; in the book, she just goes along with it. But, where was Ty? Was he there for her take down? And what did it mean? Ugh.

HollywoodLifers, will you be seeing the film and supporting Emma and Tom?

Click to Subscribe to Our HollywoodLife Daily Newsletter to get more celeb news.
  • Share This Article
  • Reddit
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Email
  • Print
  • Talk
Emma Watson Tom Hanks Tribeca Film Festival

More News From Tribeca Film Festival:

  • 'Devil's Gate' Star Amanda Schull: We Can't 'Underscore' The 'Importance Of Women' On Film
  • 'Handmaid's Tale' Bosses Hope To Inspire Women Today: If Offred Can Survive, So Can We
  • Tribeca Film Festival 2017 -- PICS

Most Read

Tiger Woods’ Kids Sam, 13, & Charlie, 11, Pictured For The 1st Time With Mom Elin Since Dad’s Car Crash

elin nordegren tiger woods kids

Ivanka Trump Frolics On A Yacht In A Bikini With Family Amid Capitol Insurrection Investigation

ivanka trump bikini

Michael Moore & Keith Olbermann Call For Texas To Go Un-Vaccinated After Governor Reopens State ‘100%’

Michael Moore and Keith Olbermann

Tom Brady Reveals The Hilarious 1st Thing Gisele Said To Him On The Field After Super Bowl Win

tom brady gisele bundchen

Michelle Obama Admits She & Barack ‘Can’t Get A Word In Edgewise’ With Sasha & Malia: We ‘Like’ That

Michelle Barack Obama

Have news, pics or video on a breaking news story?

Send us your Tip

Have news, pics or video on a breaking news story?

Send us your Tip

More From Our Brands

  • Another Mariah Carey Sibling Is Suing Over Alleged Lies in Her Memoir
    SheKnows

    Another Mariah Carey Sibling Is Suing Over Alleged Lies in Her Memoir

  • Kate Somerville’s New Anti-Aging Cream Is Like A Facial In A Bottle
    StyleCaster

    Kate Somerville’s New Anti-Aging Cream Is Like A Facial In A Bottle

  • 5 Female-Founded Small Businesses That Support Content Creators
    Blogher

    5 Female-Founded Small Businesses That Support Content Creators

  • General Hospital Spoilers March 1 – 12
    Soaps

    General Hospital Spoilers March 1 – 12

    HollywoodLife

    • About Us
    • Advertise With Us
    • Careers
    • Scoops & Corrections
    • Contact Us

    Legal

    • Privacy Policy
    • California Privacy Rights
    • AdChoices
    • Terms of Use
    • Data Policy
    • Do Not Sell My Personal Information

    News

    • Celebrity News
    • World News
    • Exclusives
    • Celebrity Babies

    Connect

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
© Copyright 2021 Hollywoodlife.com, LLC.
Powered by WordPress.com VIP
ad