‘The Bachelor’: Andi Calls Juan Pablo ‘An A–Hole’ After Spending The Night

Tue, February 25, 2014 10:06pm EDT by 49 Comments

Isn’t JP supposed to be the one sending the ladies home? We’re starting to get the feeling that if they could, the final three would have just sent him home so they could have a girls’ weekend in St. Lucia.

Apparently you don’t know someone until you spend the night with them! After their first full camera-free night with Juan Pablo in The Bachelor fantasy suites, Andi Dorfman realized that he was the last thing she wanted — and she couldn’t wait to get away from him!

Fantasy Suite Dates: Girls Drop The L-Bomb & Sleep Over

Clare, Nikki and Andi all got to spend the full day and night with Juan Pablo in St. Lucia, and it quickly heated up… but not in the best way.

Clare was the first date (which seems like she was definitely lucky!), and they spent the day like any other — making out on a yacht. When the night came, she had reservations about spending the night since he got all Juan Pablo-y after their Vietnam rendezvous. We get it, girl, but come on — the fantasy suite is the one time you’re alone together without cameras. It would be so lame to not go. Of course, they decided to and started the night with a steamy hot tub make out before the cameras cut away. Oh, and she dropped the L-bomb and made JP sweat.

Next up was Andi. She was feeling super comfortable with Juan Pablo and they headed into a waterfall in the middle of a jungle. We’ve got to say her body is extremely impressive and they looked super hot . . . and freezing under that water. Later on, he shared his concerns about a comment she had said earlier and she was just happy he had been listening to her — HILARIOUS. I was hoping Andi would leave him in the woods alone, but of course she took the key and they spent the night together.

Last but definitely not luckiest (talk about sloppy thirds) was Nikki. She came out in quite the outfit — a bikini top and Woodstock-fitting pants to go horseback riding. Of course, it was a good thing that she wore pants and not a skirt — of course JP said it’d be ok if she were just in a thong . . . gross, JuanPab. Gross. Well, the bikini came in handy as they had a swim in the ocean after the horseback ride, then headed back to the suite.

Andi Puts Juan Pablo In His Place

Each of the girls filmed a video for Juan Pablo to watch and while Nikki and Clare’s were sweet (we get it, it’s such a glorious journey you’re on), it was Andi’s that caught our attention — she told him she wanted to talk in person.

Why Andy Was Right For Calling Out Juan Pablo

Hats off to the editors of The Bachelor — after the night, Juan Pablo told the cameras how well it all went, and that she could be the one . . . and Andi told the cameras there was no way in hell that he could have thought it went well. She basically said he talked all about himself, he NAME dropped, and he talked about his previous overnight date with Clare! Andi completely bashed him, calling him offensive and thinks that he treated her wrong.

“Its extremely important for me to be with a guy who loves me more than he loves himself,” she told the cameras. Well, yeah. She also said she just wanted it all to be over. So, she told Juan Pablo right off the bat that she woke up and realized that she’s not in love with him and that she won’t be. He said “it’s ok,” which pissed her off.

Andi To Juan Pablo: There’s A Difference Between Being Honest & Being An A–hole

He told her he respected her and was appreciative that she was honest, but Andi wanted to tell him. “I want to die if I hear ‘it’s okay’ again,” she actually said. I couldn’t hear the TV over my laughter and was beyond impressed with her. So, he just changed it to “it’s fine.”

She then went off on him about the fact that he brought up Clare on the date and that he had told her she had made it there by “default” after Sharlene eliminated herself. He insisted he had never said that because he didn’t even know that word — he told her that he actually said “you barely made it.” Oh, much better.

Juan Pablo continued to dig himself a hole and she was o-v-e-r it. She even told him that there was a big difference between being honest and being an “a–hole.” After the argument, she got in the van and he said that the argument made him realize she wasn’t the one. Well, obviously.

While she did cry after she left, she actually laughed. “He doesn’t see it, it’s not a language barrier,” Andi said in the cab home. She was ready to go. She ultimately told him that she wasn’t in love — and that she was out. (Later, Andi mocked his accent on Instagram!)

Good for her! So, it’s down to Nikki and Clare. Of course at the rose ceremony, Juan Pablo told both girls to be honest and only take a rose if they were sure — and they both did.

Do you think Andi was too tough on Juan Pablo? Let us know, HollywoodLifers?

— Emily Longeretta

More ‘Bachelor’ Coverage:

  1. Andi Dorfman Disses ‘Bachelor’ Juan Pablo In Shocking New Tweet
  2. ‘The Bachelor’ Recap: Andi’s Dad Tells Juan Pablo He’s Not Good Enough
  3. ‘The Bachelor’: [Spoiler] Eliminates Herself, Breaks Juan Pablo’s Heart