Kristin Cavallari Accused Jay Cutler Of Faking Football Injury, Says Neighbor!

HollywoodLife.com has inside info from a source who lived in the same condo as former affianced couple Jay Cutler and Kristin Cavallari and they tell us all about their fights that could be heard through the walls! It's very sad that Kristin Cavallari was suddenly dumped after she'd started planning her dream wedding to Chicago Bears quarterback Jay Cutler, but it sounds like she may have dodged a bullet! An insider who lived in the same building as Kristin and Jay in Chicago tells HollywoodLife.com that the football player was "incredibly rude" to his neighbors and Kristin used to get upset over how mean he was. Even more interesting? She said he faked his playoff injury last year!

View gallery

“Jay was not nice at all. He would not talk to any of us [the neighbors] and was extremely stand-offish. He was all about himself,” reveals our source.

So how was his relationship with former fiancee Kristin? “Kristin would call Jay a loser and a p**sy, and she’d scream it at him so everyone could hear. They would have fights about Jay being too conceited. They would also argue over how mean he was to people. She would make a point of saying hello to people in the hall, just to piss him off,” our insider laughingly tells us.

In January, they got into a big blow-out argument after Jay injured his knees during the NFL playoffs. He was diagnosed with a MCL sprain. “Kristin called Jay out, saying she thought he was faking the injury and told him he was worthless.”

Our source says everyone agreed it was only a “matter of time” before they split. “Their breakup was no surprise at all to anyone who lived in the building. We thought they would end things before they got married, and if they did go through with the wedding we were convinced they’d divorce. They fought all the time, and to be honest, I blame Jay. He was awful.”

Wow! Sounds like their relationship was very unhealthy. Are you glad Kristin and Jay have split?

UPDATE: Kristin denies she ever fought with Jay about his knee, tweeting: “I never said ANYTHING about jays knee injury. I’ve always backed him 100%. Stop trying to start shit. I knw he was seriously hurt. Stop believing everything ur reading…not 1 thing has been accurate and I haven’t commented AT ALL and jay hasn’t either so its all bs”. Our source stands by their story, although we would like to clarify we did not receive this as a comment from Kristin.

Reporting by Russ Weakland

Get More From Our BFFs @ Glamour.com!

  1. 36 of the Dreamiest Beach-Friendly Wedding Dresses
  2. Healthy Summer Foods to Eat for Weight Loss
  3. Outfit Ideas: 25 Ways to Make Wardrobe Basics Look Un-Boring
  4. Rihanna’s Glamour Magazine Cover Interview Photo-Shoot Cover Gallery

More From Our Partners