Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Andy & Kirstin Say: Haley's Dominating 'American Idol' & Naima STILL Needs To Go!

Thu, March 31, 2011 5:40pm EDT by Andy Swift 4 Comments

In their fourth bicoastal battle, Andy & Kirstin butt heads over who should be sent home: Naima or Casey?

Tonight’s major double-elimination episode of American Idol is just hours away — and the staff is torn as to which contestant deserves the boot. Entertainment Editor Andy Swift thinks Casey Abrams needs to go (“America got it right last week”), while West Coast Producer Kirstin Benson still has it out for everyone’s least-favorite dancing queen, Naima Adedapo!

But before you worry about these BFFs turning into bitter foes, there is ONE thing Andy and Kirstin agree on: Casey TOTALLY looks like Yukon Cornelius from Rudolph, The Red-nosed Reindeer!

Watch Andy and Kirstin’s battle below, and then vote for who YOU think deserves to be eliminated tonight:

Loading video...