View Gallery→15 Photos

Tweet

So many questions, so few answers. Help us decipher five of last night’s biggest revelAtions!

Like all good season finales, the March 19 episode of Pretty Little Liars answered the biggest questions lingering on fans’ minds, while also introducing a million new ones to ponder during the hiatus. HollywoodLife.com picked our top five burning questions from last night’s mind-blowing finale, and we’d love to hear your theories.

1. Who Set The Fire?

Toby (Keegan Allen) is most likely going to take the fall for lighting the house on fire — the arsonist gave him the lighter once the deed was done — but I’m pretty sure he’s not the guilty party. So who is? Alison (Sasha Pieterse) pulled the girls, including Mona (Janel Parrish), out of the burning building, so I don’t think it’s her. Could it be Jenna (Tammin Sursok) or Shana (Arielle Miranda)?

2. What (Or Who) Is In The Trunk?

The final shot of the finale — if you ignore Alison literally pulling someone out of the ground — was of the girls opening Wilden’s trunk and gasping. ”Yep I know what’s/who’s in the trunk,” Nia Peeples — who plays Emily’s mom — tweeted. “Can’t tell you!”

Considering it could be a person, my money is on Jason (Drew Van Acker). Did we ever see him after his body went missing from the hospital? Did anybody even look for him? He was the only surviving member of the N.A.T. club, so he’s always been a target.

3. What’s Wilden’s Connection To Shana & Jenna?

Does Wilden (Bryce Johnson) know everyone in town? After being connected to Alison and CeCe (Vanessa Ray), the finale revealed that Jenna and Shana also know him, as they were filmed carrying his body away after Hanna’s mom ran him over. What’s going on here?!

Bonus question: How is Melissa (Torrey DeVitto) connected to the other girls?

4. Are Jenna & Shana Together?

Did anyone else feel sparks when Jenna and Shana held hands in the woods? Shana may have been comforting her (apparent) friend as she prepared to lose her sight again, but considering half the girls on this show are lesbians — or at least bisexual — would it really be that surprising to find out there was something going on there?

5. Are Toby & Mona Not-So-Bad After All?

Toby told Spencer (Troian Bellisario) that everything he was to keep her safe, but if you look back on some of the acts he committed as “A,” they were pretty heinous. As for Mona, she admitted she had no idea who the girl in the red coat was, leading the girls to believe she might not be all bad.

But who’s really telling the truth? Don’t forget: Toby and Mona are both A+ liars.

HollywoodLifers, we’ve got three months to go before the fourth season starts, so drop some comments with your best theories!

— Andy Swift

Watch: Pretty LIttle Liars Finale: The Red Coat Finally Revealed 

Follow @AndySwift

More Pretty Little Liars on HollywoodLife.com:

1. ‘Pretty Little Liars’ Season Finale Recap: Red Coat Is Finally Revealed
2. ‘Pretty Little Liars’: Is Spencer On The ‘A’ Team? Troian Bellisario Weighs In
3. ‘Pretty Little Liars’ Recap: Another Body Is Found — Is Toby Really Dead?