Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

‘Lying Game’ Shocker: Thayer Caught Kissing Emma — Or Is It Sutton?

Thu, December 27, 2012 2:29pm EDT by Andy Swift 9 Comments
Lying Game Season 2 Spoiler
Courtesy of ABC Family

A new photo from season two reveals a major twist in the show’s love triangle! (Actually, make that love square.)

The Lying Game is brilliantly complicated for so many reasons, but my favorite harrowing task is trying to tell when Alexandra Chando is playing good-twin Emma or not-so-good-twin Sutton just by looking at a photo. That inner struggle has never been more prevelant than in this shot from the Jan. 15 episode, in which one of the twins is seen swapping spit with Thayer (Christian Alexander)!

We know Thayer has a complicated history with both twins — he slept with Sutton in Los Angeles, then returned to Arizona with feelings for Emma — but it looks like it’s going to get even more complicated in season two.

And make that double once Ethan (Blair Redford) catches wind of their shenanigans!

Alexandra Chando Weighs In On ‘The Lying Game’ Love Square:

“It’s fun for me, that’s for sure,” Alexandra told at ABC Family’s Winter Wonderland event Dec. 2 in NYC. “I get to work with Blair, and Christian Alexander, who’s also fantastic. It’s interesting because they keep getting wrapped up in each other.”

But Alexandra’s next comment leads me to believe that it’s Emma, and not Sutton, kissing Thayer in the above photo.

“I think you’ll see a little more of Thayer and Emma, which I think a lot of the fans are excited about,” Alexandra revealed. “I’ve been seeing on my Twitter that they’re so excited about Thayer and Emma.”

The Lying Game returns for its second season Jan. 8 at 9 p.m. on ABC Family.

Watch our recent interview with Alexandra below, then drop a comment with your season two thoughts and theories:

— Andy Swift

More Lying Game on

  1. Winter TV 2013: ‘Carrie Diaries,’ ‘The Bachelor’ & More Shows To Watch
  2. ‘Lying Game’ First Look: Rebecca & Sutton Conspire On Season Premiere
  3. ‘The Lying Game’ Scoop: Laurel Will Learn The Twins’ Secret In Season 2