Carly Rose Sonenclar Outshines Justin Bieber With 'As Long As You Love Me'

Carly Rose Sonenclar As Long As You Love Me

Courtesy of FOX

Carly Rose’s rendition of ‘As Long As You Love Me’ on the Dec. 5 episode of ‘The X Factor’ was better than Justin Bieber’s original version! Do you agree?

Carly Rose Sonenclar blew away the competition on the Dec. 5 episode of The X Factor — she even proved to be BETTER than Justin Bieber!

“I love it when I hear unplugged versions of songs that are actually better than the original song. I mean, you sang it better than Justin did,” Demi Lovato told Carly Rose, agreeing with us!

Not only did Carly Rose make the song her own by slowing down the track, but she hit notes that Justin could only wish to achieve! (Sorry, Justin.)

“You’re why I love working in this country,” head honcho Simon Cowell added.

Who do YOU think sang “As Long As You Love Me” better, HollywoodLifers? Watch below and then vote!

Carly Rose Sonenclar’s version:

Justin Bieber’s version:

— Chris Rogers

Follow
@ChrisRogers86
More X Factor on HollywoodLife.com:

View Comment

Need a repeat button on her version.

Share this comment at

Best performance of the season.

carly is just 13 and she is this good wait till she’s justin’s age then compare her voice to his present voice.. this will deffs show carly’s better

You can’t compare a girl’s voice to a male’s voice..They have different ranges! Both acoustic versions were good. But you can’t compare..

Think about it. They are completely different…Singing wise too..

I love what you guys are up too. This kind of clever work and reporting!

Keep up the wonderful works guys I’ve added you guys to our blogroll.

nunca pueden comparar una voz de un chico con la voz de una chica..aparte nadien supera a justin!!!!

You really can’t compare a boy to a girl. They both have different voices and different heights to where their voice will go. Justin’s version is amazing and so is Carly’s.

Carly Rose Sonenclar sang it better than justin bieber tbh` ; as a belieber iam sayin that justin should step up his game on his music. :P if you know what mean , lol!

The girl that can sing this song better is Carly Rose Sonenclar

I think that Carly had an okay perforamnce. Being the major belieber that I am i think that Justin has a much much better voice. They showed his studio version of ALAYLM and if you listened to his acoustic version there would be absolutely no comparison! I am sorry to say but Justin has a much better performance than Carly