Gary Shirley Betrays Amber Portwood -- Dating The Babysitter

Courtesy of MTV, Courtesy of Twitter

Poor Amber! While the ‘Teen Mom’ star is locked behind bars, her on-again, off-again boyfriend and baby daddy is fooling around with baby Leah’s babysitter! Leah even calls her ‘mommy!’

Gary Shirley and Amber Portwood became famous on Teen Mom for their constant bickering, but now Gary has taken his betrayal one step too far — he started hooking up with baby Leah Shirley‘s babysitter — behind Amber’s back!

Gary started hanging out with Kelsi Bowden, who has a son the same age as Leah, in May when he asked her to babysit.

“While Kelsi was at home looking after Leah, Gary was running wild with his ‘Twitter girls,’” a source told OK! magazine. But babysitting soon turned to flirting when the wannabe-player started making the moves on Kelsi.

“Since Gary and Kelsi were seeing each other so much, one thing led to another and they hooked up,” the source added.

Eventually, Gary started to develop real feelings for Kelsi — and has even started to do more romantic gestures, including, “cooking her dinner, buying her flowers, and even writing her love songs,” the source added.

The problem? Amber has no idea — yet. But Amber’s brother Shawn is furious, and bound to tell his sister what’s going on.

“It’s way too soon to be in a serious relationship with someone and have Leah call her ‘Mommy,’” he told the magazine.

Ouch!

What do YOU think of Gary and Kelsi dating, HollyMoms?

OK! Magazine

– Christina Stiehl

More Gary Shirley news:

View Comment

All I have to say he should be happy …no matter who he is with ..Amber was the abuser..if it was a man hiitting a girl you all would think different…good for him Gary be happy you sure deserve it….

Share this comment at

What does Kelsi see in Gary I could never understand what Amber saw in him. Kelsi and Amber two beautiful girls that could get any guy they wanted yet they settle for the bottom of the barrel and take whale Gary. He is lazy and controlling and over weight. This Pig has absolutely nothing to offer any one. GIRLS GET SOME CONFIDENCE AND DON’T SETTLE FOR GARY GO GET A DECENT MAN ONE THAT WORKS PREFERABLY. LEAH HAS ONE MOMMY THAT IS AMBER NOT KELSI. GROW UP GARY YOU LOSER.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder..you may not see what they saw in him but I’m sure it’s deeper than the surface.

I DONT THINK IT REALLY MATTERS BECAUSE IF THEY WERE GONNA GIVE THAT LOVE LIFE ANOTHER SHOT OMG…SOMPTHING IS WRONG !!!

I say to heck with Amber. She chose to go to prison because she was to self-centered and too lazy to better herself for herself or her child. She chose herself over her child which is one thing a mother should NOT do. Screw her. But as for gary, there’s nothing wrong with him moving on and dating anyone but he should NOT be letting Leah call that girl ‘mommy’. It’s way too early in the relationship for one, and if things dont work out how does he think that will affect Leah? Leahs real mother has already been in and out of her life practically since birth so it would be even worse if (and most likely when) this new girl leaves just as Leah is getting attached. That is emotionally scarring for a child no matter how old. I really feel sorry for Leah because both of her parents are not making the best decisions for her…They are just thinking of themselves…

Really? Do you not know anything about addiction? Amber made what she thought was the best decision to get sober. That’s not selfish, that’s being an adult. I’m not saying Amber was always the best person, but she was/is a sick person who deserves to get help and turn her life around. If prison will do that better than another failed rehab trip, awesome.

i love teen mom

oh yeah Amber really lost a great catch there, NOT. Would anyone feel upset if Gary said goodbye to them. This is a blessing. This guy is an obsese hot mess. Who cares who he whales on next!

Amber CHOSE a life in prison. She wanted to be there. Amber and Gary are not together and are horrible together. Leah is better off if Gary is with someone new and is happy. This site is so annoying.

Gary is hardly betraying Amber! She abused him mentally & physically, and did not want to be with him, as shown in the men she dated, even after rehab. Amber made a selfish, very selfish choice to go to prison. I hope the babysitter can give Leah guidance an love that her own mother was too selfish to do in the most formative years of her life!

Has he done what he should do yet…take Leah to see her mother?

Funny… but the babysitter she’s yes HOT and Young..

uhmm this girl looks like Amber. LOL. I see why the poor child is confused. I don’t see why ANYONE on earth, especially a pretty girl like Kelsi want to be with gary. On the up and plus hopefully Leah will FINALLY have a positive role model and someone who looks after her properly.

I said the same exact thing! She looks like amber when she was thinner!

They broken up! why r u so DRAMATIC with the tittle jajaja

its messed up that a tramp like that will get to the next level with gary. but its been amber’s fault for being back and forth and not really knowing what she wants. a man won’t wait for such a long time to come around thats why they do this stupid decisions. after all therapy couple hasn’t worked for them.

Or maybe this story is lies… ever think of that?? lmao

I thought they were broken up? Who cares?

Kelsi is very pretty! I hope Gary finds happiness. He’s been a dad to Leah while Amber’s just been neglecting Leah and acting like a psycho. Her poor-me attitude is ridiculous.

Amber doesn’t deserve to be Leah’s mom. Anyone in prison shouldn’t be a parent. But it is kind of weird that Leah’s calling Kelsi “mommy”. Well, I guess that’s who’s ACTING like the mommy, so… Yeah.