Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Kim Kardashian & Beyonce: New Proof Of Their Feud

Tue, September 4, 2012 5:07pm EDT by 13 Comments
FameFlynet, Courtesy of

Everyone in Hollywood is wishing Beyonce their best on her special day, but where was Kim and Kanye’s birthday message to the pop star? Read on for more details!

Beyonce is receiving best wishes from the world on her 31st birthday, but Kim Kardashian and Kanye West’s missing message didn’t go unnoticed on her star-studded birthday card!

“For Dear Sweet BB on the occasion of her 31st birthday…We love you so very much. Love, Gwyneth, Chris, Apple, Moses,” Gwyneth Paltrows family wrote on the card.

“Beyonce, Happy Birthday to youuuu!! I love you so very much. I am so thankful you’re in my life! Love Always, Michelle Williams!,” Michelle Williams wrote.

“God blessed me with one of the greatest gifts in my life on Sept 4, 1981. Happy Birthday love Mom,” her mother, Tina Knowles, wrote.

Other friends that joined in on the fun included Jay-Z’s mom and the Team at Beyond Productions, but it seemed a little strange that Jay-Z’s BFF Kanye and his girlfriend Kim didn’t jump on the bandwagon. More proof Kim and Beyonce aren’t friends?

Hmm! What do YOU think, HollywoodLifers? Are you surprised Kim’s signature is missing from the birthday card? Weigh in below!

More Kardashian News:

  1. Rob Kardashian Blasts Kim: She ‘Is So Selfish’
  2. ‘Oprah’s Next Chapter’ Recap: Kim Kardashian Wants To Marry Kanye West
  3. ‘KUWTK’: Rob Kardashian Cries During His Family Intervention