Leah Messer In Tortured Love Triangle With Ex-Husband Corey Simms & Fiancée Jeremy Calvert

Wed, March 7, 2012 12:12pm EDT by 30 Comments

Who will desperate Leah Messer choose? She can’t stop crying as she struggles to decide who she should love.

Leah Messer, 19, gushed waterfalls at the Teen Mom 2 reunion in New York City on March 3 when Dr. Drew Pinksy asked about her relationship with her ex-hubby Corey Simms, their shared custody of 2-year-old twins Aliannah and Aleeah, and her new fiancée Jeremy Calvert.

“She misses Corey, and part of her wishes she could make things work,” says a source close to Leah, who’s a stay-at-home in West Virginia. “But another part of her loves Jeremy and wants to start a clean slate with him.”

And apparently, Corey misses her, too.

“Corey likes Jeremy because he’s good to his girls, but he’d take Leah back in a second,” a source reveals.

Despite Leah’s cheating on Corey a week before their October 2010 wedding, the two tried to make things work out between them last summer, but in the end, things fizzled out. Leah felt no choice but to move on with her life.

Last August her Facebook friendship with pipeline engineer Jeremy, 23, blossomed into a relationship and the two got engaged and were pregnant by December. Unfortunately, Leah miscarried in January, and she took it as a sign that maybe her relationship with Jeremy wasn’t right.

“Jeremy knows Leah isn’t as certain about their relationship now,” a source asserts. “Their engagement is definitely on a rocky path.”

More ‘Teen Mom’ News:

  1. ‘Teen Mom’ Stars — Inside Their Pricey NYC Weekend Reunion
  2. ‘Teen Mom’ Casts Reunite In NYC — Find Out Who’s Banned From Coming
  3. ‘Teen Mom’ Casts In NYC Pics