Babysitter Charged With 9-Year-Old Aliahna Lemmon's Horrific Death

Tue, December 27, 2011 2:47pm EST by 20 Comments

A babysitter made shocking headlines when police found dismembered body parts of a missing Indiana girl in his freezer! So horrifying!

It’s every parent’s worst nightmare — Sick with the flu, 28-year-old Tarah Souders left her 9-year-old daughter Aliahna Lemmon and two other daughters with their neighbor and trusted family friend Mike Plumadore, 39. Little Aliahna was reported missing late Dec. 23, and by Dec. 26 her dismembered body was discovered in the man’s freezer! Now police say Mike is responsible for the grizzly, violent murder of the young girl, according to The Daily Mail.

Police say that Mike led them to his freezer where they were shocked to find the girl’s hands and feet. The rest of her body had been tossed into a dumpster.

Although he wouldn’t say why he committed such a cruel and heartless murder, Mike admitted to police that he bashed her head with a brick and used a hack saw to cut up the rest of her body.

Mike isn’t listed on Indiana’s registered sex offenders list, but he has past convictions in Florida and North Carolina for offenses including trespassing and assault.

“It was a horrific crime,” Allen County Sheriff Ken Fries told reporters on Dec. 26. “Probably worse than you can imagine.”

What a senseless, horrible crime!

More crime stories on

  1. Mom Shoots Her Daughter & Dad After Sending Her Husband On An Errand
  2. A Father Accidentally Dropped Marijuana Into His 18-Month-Old Son’s Lunch
  3. A Mom Tried To Sell Her 8-Month-Old For $7,000