Tweet

Uh oh! Could Toby be the one who ‘goes missing’ — or worse, ‘dies’ — on ‘Pretty Little Liars’ this season?

When that creepy little doll urged Spencer (Troian Bellisario) to “keep Toby safe” on the Pretty Little Liars fall finale, she wasn’t kidding! In a text message sent exclusively to HollywoodLife.com, “A” reveals that he/she will be particularly interested in Toby (Keegan Allen) when the show returns Jan. 2 — more so than any other boy in Rosewood.

“Toby… Wait. What do you mean by interested?” was the response I got from “A” when I asked which of the Liars‘ suitors “A” will be most interested in when the show returns.

This is actually a pretty loaded statement when you consider how much vested interested “A” has in the other girls’ boyfriends, Ezra (Ian Harding) and Caleb (Tyler Blackburn.) For “A” to set his/her sights on Toby above the others must mean he/she has something particularly twisted up his/her sleeve.

Do you think we should all say a little prayer for Toby before the show’s Jan. 2 winter premiere? Drop your best theories in the comments section below!

— Andy Swift

Follow Andy on Twitter for more Pretty Little Liars scoop