'The Lying Game' Winter Premiere First Look: Why Is Emma Crying?

Tue, November 29, 2011 8:30pm EST by 8 Comments
Bill Matlock/ABC Family

New episode of ‘The Lying Game’ return Jan. 2, and HollywoodLife.com has your exclusive first look!

Emma (Alexandra Chando) has always been The Lying Game‘s tougher twin, so I can only imagine what’s reducing her to tears in this brand-new photo from the show’s Jan. 2 winter premiere, obtained exclusively by HollywoodLife.com. Maybe it has something to do with Sutton’s car being found at the bottom of the lake? Good thing she has Ethan’s (Blair Redford) shoulder to cry on — for now!

According to the episode’s official description on ABCFamily.com, “Emma and Ethan’s … relationship is tested by questionable motives and accusations.”

It doesn’t sound like anything is going right in Emma’s life!

So why do YOU think she’s crying? Is she mourning the loss of her dear, psychotic sister? Is Ethan breaking up with her? Or is she merely cracking under the pressure of her double life?

Hit up the comments section with your best theories, including — I’m sure — that the girl in the photo is actually Sutton. And head over to ABC Family’s Lying Game section for more info.

— Andy Swift

Follow Andy on Twitter for more Lying Game scoop

Oh, and here’s one more shot of Emma and Ethan from the premiere — but only because I love you so much: