Key Comments: Most Of You Thought Demi Lovato's 'Skyscraper' Was More Inspirational Than Selena Gomez's 'Who Says'!

Thu, July 14, 2011 3:48pm EDT by 18 Comments

100’s of people commented they preferred Demi Lovato’s inspirational song more than Selena Gomez’s!

We asked you HollywoodLifers to give us your opinion on which song you liked better between Selena Gomez‘s “Who Says” and Demi Lovato‘s new single “Skyscraper”–and boy did you let your voices be heard!

The majority of people (51.3%) said they loved Demi‘s hit song more than Selena‘s! Others took Selena’s side, with 38.8% of people saying that her song was more inspirational. People from both sides were heated about their opinions! Check out these comments from supporters of Demi and Selena:

Team Demi
LOVATIC***
Demi is amazing!!
Her voice resinates from the speakers and she sounds amazing!
There is absolutely NO comparison between Selena and Demi because DEMI LOVATO won!!
I mean…#1 on iTunes within 20 hours is unbelievable – this is because of her talent, raw emotions that got her there=)
I hope the world will begin to respect and aknowledge her, her voice is AMAZING whereas Selenas…

Dear Bonnie: Demi has overcome some serious obstacles in her life and for that she has not been in the music industry lately but now with her “SKYSCRAPER” single, this is her long awaited comeback!

It is proven that it is long awaited because she beat the odds of Lady Gaga, Katy Perry, Adele, Beyonce and dominated the iTunes charts to #1 within 20 hours without a promo!

Why can’t you see this and truly attribute her success by glorifying her success in a main article JUST ABOUT HER without comparing her to Selena Gomez…

Ally: omg i LOVE Demi’s new song definitely something all girls can relate to everyone go through there rough patch of feeling like nothing and everyone is against u very inspirational.n who says is just an anthem for girls who have been called UGLY.Demi is definitely the better singer. she needs no auto tune unlike selena gomez.Omg have you ever heard selena sing live its horrible. shes only good on the low parts. but Demi is just the total package.

You praised Selena’s success on her own – Just let Demi shine as the star she is…

Lilly: Both songs are good. But,Demi lovato is an inspiration and a strong person! For god sakes shes the only one in disney channel who does not use auto tune, you can actually hear the pain in this song . i love demi lovato !!!! <3

Team Selena

Kelly: Selena Gomezis Awesome!!!
People say she hasn’t been through much on her life but she was also bullied when she was young!
She was even locked in a washroom in her school
And she has been getting lot of hate nowadays
I won’t say she is a better singer than Demi but she has gotten so much better!!!!
And u prefer Selenas song better cause I just do!!!
And all you haters need to STFU

Selenator: All you Lovato fans hating on Selena are full of anger and hatred. You say that Demi has suffered and then you do the exact same thing to Selena! Selena is more talented, inspirational and kind than you will ever be. We support Selena forever no matter what. Your hate filled words don’t bring her down. She takes strength from her fans.
#SelenaAmazing

Gabrielle: All you Lovato fans hating on Selena are full of anger and hatred. You say that Demi has suffered and then you do the exact same thing to Selena! Selena is more talented, inspirational and kind than you will ever be. We support Selena forever no matter what. Your hate filled words don’t bring her down. She takes strength from her fans.

#SelenaAmazing

Not everyone picked a favorite. Close to 9% of you said BOTH songs are great!

Team Demi & Selena

Julie: some people are saying oh, demis song is better because she went through all of those troubles. yes, demi did go through that and i still love her and i <3 this song but i also love selenas song and she has been through the hate that beliebers send her because she is dating justin and her song is about being who you are and ignoring the hate which relates to her being hated on by the beliebers so this has a real relation to her life just like demis song does and plus i am proud of selena for not caving into the fame and doing something horrible like so many celebrities have done. so i support both the songs and they are both great so why cant we just leave it at that instead of starting a war over which song is better and more inspirational.

Sandra: I think we Selenators all must agree, It’s Demi’s moment & Selena supports her 100%!
We Selenators & The Lovatics need to support each other, not create hate. I am in such agreement with you, both have a very beautiful message, and yes Demi is a much gifted singer, Selena & we know so! She doesn’t plan on giving challenges to someone she deeply cares about!
SELENA & DEMI FOREVERRRRRR, Capeche?
Damn it, ENJOY THE MUSIC PEOPLE!!!

Then there were some of you that thought NEITHER song was inspirational!

Ami: The truth is that i don’t like either of them . I mean their music ,which is soo common . Of caurse it’s not that i hate them or sth like that. Just the question of the ‘Most Popular Inspirational Song Of The Summer!’ seems quite silly 2 me when their songs are not at all inspirational ,with no True and Deep meaning (only superficial ) and everyone will forget them soon…Plz don’t reply to me ,accusing me etc . Just think clearly and truly , even you ”crazy” fans .. Are they really worthy singers ? Are their song really inspirational?And even if u reply yes because you just ‘Love’ them so much.. Are they themselves worthy of being followed by millions of people .Of caurse not, they were just lucky .And this is the only reason you must be happy 4 them. Learn to look up to worthy people.. thank you 4 your time :)

So BFFs, are you shocked by these comments? Sound off below!

-Josh DeMilta

Read More On Selena And Demi!

  1. Did Joe Turn Demi Off From Guys?
  2. Watch Out, Selena! Demi’s New Single, ‘Skyscraper,’ Might Be The Most Popular Song Of The Summer!
  3. Is Demi Recording A Duet With Chris Brown?