Nikki Reed Still Hot & Heavy With 'American Idol' Finalist Paul McDonald!

Fri, May 13, 2011 11:52am EST by Add first Comment

What do you think of this surprise couple?

When reports first emerged of a romance between American Idol finalist Paul McDonald and Breaking Dawn star Nikki Reed, a lot of people were skeptical. Us included. But Paul, 26, and Nikki, 22, looked totally in love May 12 at a Prince concert in Los Angeles, according to eyewitnesses. Plus, can we please talk about how they totally coordinated their outfits? Very cute.