'American Idol' Says 'Bye' To Its Hunk…And The Writing Is On The Wall For The Next Two!

Stefano Langone said goodbye tonight on ‘American Idol,’ but for a minute, we though it might be Haley Reinhart or Jacob Lusk. Are YOU bummed Stefano got the boot?

And then there were…six. After two consecutive weeks in the bottom three, Stefano Langone sang his swan song on American Idol April 21. But it wasn’t obvious who was getting the boot this week…

Also in the bottom was one of the last two girls — Haley Reinhart, who’s been in jeopardy FOUR times now — and also, Jacob Lusk, who had a technical glitch at the beginning of his performance the night before.

For the first time in awhile, I wasn’t totally shocked by the bottom three. I feel those were the appropriate contestants to be there.

At this point, only three contestants have been consecutively safe — Lauren Alaina, Scotty McCreery and James Durbin — and I think those will be our final three.

Who do YOU think is going to win season 10 of American Idol? Were you sad to say goodbye to Stefano, or was it his time? Sound off below!

Email me! | Follow me on Twitter | Become a Facebook fan

GET MORE ON AMERICAN IDOL!:

View Comment

i think haley has the ability to be a dark horse, and lauren has the ability to be another “surprise” to go (a la pia). i’m hoping for james, haley, and casey or jacob in the top three (even though haley has had such a precarious ride), and still hoping for james for the win. i’m worried that jacob has been mind-f’ed b/c that producer is always trying to reel him in from being too corny, but randy is saying to let loose, and i don’t know if he’s going to be able to sing with free abandon again— which is the only way he’s going to stay. nerves might kill him. sigh. in my perfect world, scotty goes next, then lauren (despite her gorgeous voice), then it gets hard… it really is all about how makes the right song choices, and not only doesn’t CHOKE, but really connects and shares with the audience… i don’t think either lauren or scotty are good at connecting and sharing, b/c they’re too young. but we’ll see what america says.

Share this comment at

I wasn’t that surprised, but kind of wished it had been Jacob instead. All of his peers seem to think he’s a diva and he seems like one to me too. Ever since his comment about “America not wanting to look at themselves in the mirror” I’ve been over him.

yah, that comment was a little much… but now i’m worried that he has lost his mojo a bit b/c he was so high from the “god’s gift” comments, and now he seems a little confused. he may have come out with some annoying comments, but i do think he has a beautiful voice, and a not common style, and i’d love to see him stick around and show us some more of his stuff b/c he’s so passionate (usually).

Not toooo suprised, but thought maybe it was James turn. I do hope the final three will be Casey,Scotty and James…..hope song pics are better next week……think that means sooooo much.

I´m not really that surprised and I think he should leave even before Pia Toscano. Stefano has a nice voice and can really sing, no doubt about that. But we have a lot of singers like him, honestly I can´t see anything special on him being an american Idol.