'American Idol' Love Triangle! Should Pia Toscano Date Mark Ballas Or Stefano Langone?

Wed, April 13, 2011 3:28pm EST by 6 Comments

Cast-off Pia is reportedly torn between ‘Idol’ finalist Stefano & ‘Dancing with the Stars’ pro Mark. Help her choose!

American, you made the decision to boot Pia Toscano from American Idol last week, and now we’ve got another very important decision for you to make for us: Who should Pia date? According to a new report in Star magazine, Pia is torn between fellow Idol finalist Stefano Langone and Dancing with the Stars pro Mark Ballas, who she’s been spotted with recently.

“Stefano and Pia clicked immediately and soon realized their flirting was something more,” a source tells the mag. “They made a pact not to go public, but all the other contestants knew they were together.”

But now that Pia’s no longer seeing Stefano on a weekly basis, he’s slipping further from her mind. She met Mark on the lot where both Idol and DWTS are taped, and he eventually asked her out. Stefano doesn’t seem too pleased by their new closeness, as a source tells Star he’s still trying to get in contact with Pia.

“Stefano was definitely under the impression that they were in a committed relationship,” the source says. “He never saw this coming. He’s been calling and texting her, letting her know how much he still cares about her.”