Are 'American Idol' Finalists Paul & Lauren Secretly Dating 'Twilight' Stars?

Thu, April 7, 2011 7:35pm EST by 21 Comments

We don’t know if we can handle two of our biggest obsessions coming together like this!

If you thought Haley Reinhart and Casey AbramsAmerican Idol romance was hot, wait till you hear who fellow contestants Paul McDonald and Lauren Alaina, 16, have reportedly been chatting with! Paul, 26, has now had several Skype dates with Twilight star Nikki Reed, 22, according to Us Weekly, while Lauren has been doing the same with Taylor Lautner!

We guess that explains the heart shape Lauren made with her hands on the March 30 episode of Idol. (Was that a message to Taylor?)