Andy & Kirstin Say: Haley's Dominating 'American Idol' & Naima STILL Needs To Go!

Thu, March 31, 2011 5:40pm EDT by 4 Comments

In their fourth bicoastal battle, Andy & Kirstin butt heads over who should be sent home: Naima or Casey?

Tonight’s major double-elimination episode of American Idol is just hours away — and the HollywoodLife.com staff is torn as to which contestant deserves the boot. Entertainment Editor Andy Swift thinks Casey Abrams needs to go¬†(“America got it right last week”), while West Coast Producer Kirstin Benson still has it out for everyone’s least-favorite dancing queen, Naima Adedapo!

But before you worry about these BFFs turning into bitter foes, there is ONE thing Andy and Kirstin agree on: Casey TOTALLY looks like Yukon Cornelius from Rudolph, The Red-nosed Reindeer!

Watch Andy and Kirstin’s battle below, and then vote for who YOU think deserves to be eliminated tonight:

Loading video...