Andy & Kirstin Say: Ashthon Should Be Sent Home On 'American Idol' & Naima Should Never Dance Again!

Thu, March 10, 2011 6:54pm EDT by 5 Comments

Plus, in their first-ever bicoastal video battle, Andy & Kirstin debate Scotty McCreery’s southern schtick!

Before you watch American Idol‘s huge elimination episode tonight, see what HollywoodLife.com‘s Andy Swift and Kirstin Benson have to say about the Top 13! While they agree Ashthon Jones deserves the first boot, they’re divided over another major issue: the very existence of Scotty McCreery. Kirstin melts over the crooner’s southern charm, while Andy wishes Scotty would try singing out of both sides of his mouth just once. Watch the debate and let us know what YOU think about Idol‘s top 13.

Disclaimer: Please excuse the questionable quality of our video. It shall improve over time!

Loading video...

Agree with Andy? Click here to follow him on Twitter!

Agree with Kirstin? Click here to follow her on Twitter!