Kirstin Says: Need Help Voting? Here Are My Top 5 Guys On 'American Idol!'

Tue, March 1, 2011 9:30pm EST by 6 Comments

Getty Images

I can’t believe we have to cut seven guys from American Idol. There are at least 10 who deserve to stay!

Wow! It’s hard to believe, but American Idol has already turned into Sophie’s Choice. Tonight, March 1, we witnessed more flawless performances than our typical Top 5 deliver — and it’s only down to the Top 12 guys. How they want us to whittle it down to five of our favorites is beyond me.

Seeing it on the small screen was pretty awesome, but honestly, it was even cooler watching the taping last week in person. The crowd’s energy was electrifying and guys had the presence of rock stars. Judging from tonight’s performances, here are the guys who I think should be put through to the Top 5 slots:

1. James Durbin, 22: At first, James reminded me of the poor man’s Adam Lambert, but after seeing him live, it’s obvious he was born to be on stage and make a name for himself. Jennifer Lopez says his performances are “organic” and it’s true. Nothing seems rehearsed or phony, James sings and moves from the heart and it shows.

2. Casey Abrams, 20: Casey had a health scare last week that landed him in the hospital and no one was sure whether or not he’d make it to performances. Luckily he did — his sultry rendition of “I Put A Spell On You” had everyone in the crowd instantly on their feet. He reminds me of Taylor Hicks — wise beyond his years.

3. Scotty McCreery, 17: Oh, Scotty. Where to begin? First of all, confession time: After Scotty sang, I was the first one on my feet. I have an inappropriate crush on this country crooner. He’s just too cute and I’m already counting the days til he turns 18. (Yes, I know…weird.) Anyway, Scotty was born to sing country and I love how the judges recognize this in him and aren’t pushing him to sing outside his niche.

4. Paul McDonald, 26: How can you not love Paul? Just one look at his ultra-white smile warms my heart. Plus, his rendition of Rod Stewart‘s hit single was spot on. Not only does he have character, but this Nashville-native is comfortable moving around the stage and it’s obvious he’s been performing for a loooong time. He deserves more time on the show…even if his voice has a specific (and dare I say, one dimensional?) tone.

5. Jacob Lusk, 23: Last, but certainly not least, is Mr. Jacob Lusk, our token gospel singer. Listening to Jacob sing in person is indescribable — it’s an out-of-body experience. I get chills just thinking about it. As the judges said, Jacob’s voice is “divine intervention.” American Idol is lucky to have him.

The other seven guys were all outstanding as well (except maybe Jordan Dorsey, who made the worst song choice of all time with Usher‘s “OMG”). However, the five I listed stood out as being more polished and extraordinary than the rest. Luckily, it’s rumored the judges will each pick a wild card contestant, which will give us a Top 13, versus a Top 12.

Which guys do YOU think will make it to the top? Who is your favorite? Sound off below!

Click here to see Chris Medina Bring Out The Humanity In Diva J-Lo!

Click here for ‘American Idol’ Recap: Was Chris Medina Wrongfully Eliminated?

Click here Is ‘American Idol’ Star Thia Megia The New Charice?

Leave a Reply

To comment, please fill in the fields below, enter your comment and select the Comment button.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

View Comment


Posted at 10:10 PM on March 3, 2011  

I don’t love Paul : / I do love the rest of your choices. Can’t wait to see who makes it to the top twelve.

Share this comment at Share with Twitter


Posted at 11:44 AM on March 2, 2011  

Totally agree what a show, and will be waiting each week to see the progress….looking forward to the girls, and what acts to follow…. whew……

Share this comment at Share with Twitter


Posted at 8:50 AM on March 2, 2011  

That would be my top five as well. Those five did the best. Some of the others were good but not as good as those five. I really like Paul’s version of Rod’s song. I love that song period. He has such a unique voice. I agree Kirstin on the Scotty thing. He is a cutie and my Lord can that kid can sing. How can someone that young have a voice like that. It’s amazing. Can’t wait to see what the girls bring tonight. I’m liking the show this year.

Share this comment at Share with Twitter


Posted at 1:00 AM on March 2, 2011  

Really like your analysis…..but think Stefano needs to be included in the mix. Singing a Bruno Mars song is TOUGH….and although he missed the super-high note, thought he nailed the rest of it. Paul was (unfortunately) covered up too much by the music behind him.

Share this comment at Share with Twitter

Lorel Cornman

Posted at 12:49 AM on March 2, 2011  

Watched last week for the first time because of Casey Abrams. Loved the show. Loved the judges, who I thought were kind, thoughtful and showed respect for these young performers. Was really impressed w/ the high caliber of each performance. Will no doubt watch again.

Share this comment at Share with Twitter

Will Johnson

Posted at 12:45 AM on March 2, 2011  

Great group of varied performers. Great judges who had kindness and respectfulness for what the young people have gone through to get here. I’ve never watched this show until last week. I’ll watch again.

Share this comment at Share with Twitter