Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Wow! Does 'American Idol' ALREADY Regret Picking Jennifer Lopez & Steven Tyler As Judges?

Tue, August 10, 2010 9:38am EDT by Chloe Melas 5 Comments
Getty Images (3)

Getty Images (3)

American Idol might have jumped the shark! New reports say J. Lo, Steven and Randy have never even been in the same room together!

It’s been an ongoing debate as to whether American Idol’s executive producer, Nigel Lythgoe, made the right decision by doing a little “spring cleaning” with the show’s judges — and now TMZ is reporting that Nigel never tested out the chemistry between Jennifer Lopez, Steven Tyler and Randy Jackson before deciding to make them the new face of Idol! Back when Nigel hired Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul and Randy, the three went out to dinners and Simon and Randy even reportedly went to strip clubs to get to know each other! This new trio hasn’t even tried to bond like the original.

We were shocked when we learned that Ellen DeGeneres quit and reports that Kara DioGuardi was fired. But now we find it even more outrageous that these three judges could potentially begin season 10 cold!

But don’t freak out just yet! Sources are telling TMZ that J. Lo and Steven haven’t officially signed their contracts — so there’s a chance we might not even see them this January after all.

—Chloe Melas