Tweet

Elton, we bet you would fill Simon’s shoes better than anyone!

Hey Elton John, we hear rumors that you are thinking about taking over Simon Cowell‘s position as judge on American Idol. Could this be true? If so, we can’t wait! You were an awesome guest judge on Season 3, and your personality couldn’t be more entertaining. Seriously, if Simon leaves, we are going to need some hard-handed flair and drama. Who could better fill this spot than you Elton?

“An American Idol spy tells us the talk on the set is … Elton John,” reports TMZ! Gosh, we hope this is true!

Elton, you know the industry better than anyone else — and, we bet you dish on those contestants like we have never before seen!

- Lindsey DiMattina

Get More on American Idol:

1. ‘Get Your Pants Off The Ground!’ Watch As ‘Pants On The Ground’ Makes ‘American Idol’ History
2. EXCLUSIVE! Taylor Hicks Warns This Season’s ‘American Idol’ Hopefuls: If You Use Your Cell Phone, You’ll Lose ‘Idol’